2026 Theodore Roosevelt Police Award · Western New York
This year’s recipient is Detective Sergeant Nicholas Militello. Officer Nick Militello is a veteran police officer of 14 years, assigned to the Buffalo Police Department's B district. The son of a BPD detective and swat member, and a lifelong City of Buffalo westside resident where his family has generational roots, he displays a daily passion and work ethic that is unmatched.
As Detective Sergeant, Nick often works all hours of the day responding to crisis situations, investigating heinous crimes, coordinating between patrol and investigators, preparing sensitive court cases, recognizing and resolving district issues and proactively addressing them before they become larger ones. In addition to commanding a team of detectives whom he assigns each case to and who has shown great tenacity and dedication by handling thousands of incident investigations both large and small and dedi cating the same amount of work to them all regardless of scale.
Nick has been instrumental in handling local major investigations involving serial robberies, larcenies, assaults, gang members, car thefts, shots fired incidents, narcotics rings, grand larcenies, shootings, frauds and more as well as national incidents w here he has worked with other outside agencies to combine intelligence to investigate and solve multijurisdictional crimes. These crimes have included the incident involving the Theodore Roosevelt pocket watch which was stolen from the TR Site and missing for 37 years until finally being returned in 2023. Det. Sgt. Nick Millitello worked with National Park Service and FBI on the case for the valued item belonging to our 26th president.
Nick has done this all, largely while working in the city’s most high volume and logistically demanding district, often lending a hand outside of his job responsibilities to help the other departments and responding to active calls even when not requested, and even frequently assisting citizens at the front desk to support other department members in need and to ensure that victims receive immediate professional service in moments of need.
Det. Sgt. Militello suffers from a neurological disorder which causes vertigo and headaches, which can be exacerbated by stress and long hours of work. Despite this, Nick dedicates himself completely on a regular basis even when he is at home with his fami ly, still taking phone calls and coming in to work additional hours, without regard for himself or his personal well -being all in an effort to solve crimes, help provide quality service to city of Buffalo and provide leadership to his team of detectives. Militello was nominated by Chief of the Buffalo Police Department's B-District, Tommy Champion, because of his relentless work ethic and his dedication to service.